Bank of the West v. The 26′ Well Craft Scarab (Ship)

The Defendant marine insurer sought leave to amend its pleading to plead a limitation period contained in its policy. At first instance the Prothonotary denied the application without giving reasons. On appeal, the motions Judge noted the general rule is to allow amendments at any stage of an action provided there is no prejudice or injustice to the other party that cannot be compensated for in costs. Given that the proceeding had not advanced significantly and the Plaintiff was unable to identify any particular prejudice, the Judge allowed the appeal and gave leave to the Defendant to plead the limitation period defence.